← Back to Journal

IVYH Journal

When a good habit becomes another project

Tracking can reveal progress, but it can also change what a habit means. Let the question and the decision determine which numbers belong.

My Store Admin2026-11-183 min read
Två personer vid ett bord med en bärbar dator och IVYH-flaskor / Two people at a table with a laptop and IVYH bottles.

A walk can be a chance to get outside for a while. It can also become a distance that needs to beat yesterday's. Neither is wrong, but a step counter answers different questions depending on what you wanted from the walk in the first place.

Tracking helps when the feedback makes a relevant decision clearer. It becomes less useful when the number starts to replace the purpose. For a considered everyday habit, the question is not simply whether you can track it, but what you intend to do with the information.

More activity is one answer, not the whole answer

Across six experiments, researcher Jordan Etkin examined what happens when people can see how much they are doing. Tasks included reading and walking. Measurement often increased the amount of activity, but could also reduce enjoyment and make the activity feel more like work.[1]

That distinction matters if you read for pleasure. More pages completed need not mean a better time with a book. The experiments were short, and several used student samples. They identify a possible cost of measurement, rather than showing that everyone who tracks a habit will enjoy it less.

There is also a substantial reason to use feedback when the aim is to move more. A systematic review in the BMJ brought together randomised studies of activity monitors in adults. Interventions giving adults feedback from physical activity monitors increased activity on average compared with control groups. Results varied, and the authors noted that effects could be overestimated.[2]

Those findings need not conflict. One research question concerns how an experience changes; the other asks whether activity increases. A number can help you pursue a goal without describing everything that makes the habit worth keeping.

Let the question choose the measure

Suppose you want to find out whether a lunchtime walk fits into your working week. A brief note about when it happened and what got in the way may be more useful than speed and distance. If you are training towards a particular finishing time, pace has a clear job to do. These are hypothetical examples, not rules for anyone's training.

Try naming the decision before collecting the data: “If I saw this information, what would I do differently?” An unclear answer may call for a better question rather than more metrics. The work of collecting information counts too. In a study of people's reactions to illustrated self-monitoring systems, participants described both the value of awareness and the tedium of recording. The study examined their opinions, not the effects of long-term use.[3]

A considered choice need not be reconsidered daily

You can choose something carefully and then let it have a place in your day without evaluating it every evening. A product can be assessed through its contents, clear information and whether it serves your purpose. Logging its use in an app, however, does not establish a product effect.

If you want to track an optional everyday habit, decide when you will look back at the notes and what decision they should support. A chosen moment for reflection is different from revisiting the whole arrangement after each individual day. This discussion concerns personal lifestyle tracking, not measurements or checks agreed with a healthcare professional.

Keep a measure when it helps you make a decision that matters. If a walk is mainly a chance to get outside, a slow outing with no distance recorded may still have served its purpose. Leave room for what you originally wanted from the habit, even when the app asks for a number.

Sources

  1. Jordan Etkin: The Hidden Cost of Personal Quantification (2016)
  2. Larsen et al.: Effectiveness of physical activity monitors in adults (BMJ, 2022)
  3. Orji et al.: Tracking feels oppressive and “punishy” (2018)

Keep exploring

Back to Journal Frequently asked questions